Wednesday, August 18, 2004

Ecclesiastes and the Workplace (Part 2)

The Preacher's Method


Before exploring the meaning of labor in the book of Ecclesiastes we need to understand the Preacher’s method. The issue here is that it can be a confusing book. It can be frustrating to us. We can think that it is somehow not true; it’s so dark, and so different from anything else we read in our Bibles. It can raise more questions for us than it solves. Other books raise similar questions for us. How are we to interpret Job for example? A lot of what his so-called comforters say seems right to us, but they are indicted in the end (Job 42:7-9). And, Job himself says early on that we ought to overlook the ranting of a depressed man (Job 6:26). So how much of what he says should we take seriously? The point is simply that we need to understand the purpose and function of the different types of literature we have in scripture. We need to be careful in our interpretation. So, we need to be sure we understand what the Preacher is trying to do.

The Preacher sets out to examine the meaning of life by reason (1:13a,17; 2:3,12; 7:25; 8:16; 9:1), experimentation (2:1; 7:23), and observation (3:10,12,14,16; 4:1,4,7,15; 5:13,18; 6:1; 7:15; 8:9,10,17; 9:11,13; 10:5,7) In other words, the Preacher, the wisest of all men, engaged in empirical research into the meaning of human activity. In this book he reports his observations, and offers his own theistic interpretation of the meaning of life. His observations are common to us all. We all with similar wisdom ought to be able to see the same things. We all, whether we accept the revelation contained in the Bible or not, are able to weigh the truth of his assertions.

The Method's Limits

Even though the Preacher asserts our accountability to God, and engages in his examination under the self-conscious awareness of the superintendence of God over the world, his conclusions do not go beyond what is revealed about God in nature and in our consciences.[i] Romans 1 tells us that the revelation of God in nature, that is, apart from the Bible, is enough to constrain us to worship him, to provoke thanksgiving, and to make us accountable to him, knowing that our moral obedience is a matter of life or death.

20 For his invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse. 21 For although they knew God, they did not honor him as God or give thanks to him, but they became futile in their thinking, and their foolish hearts were darkened. (Rom 1:20, 21 NASB)

32 Though they know God's decree that those who practice such things deserve to die, they not only do them but give approval to those who practice them. (Rom 1:32 NASB)

The Preacher’s conclusions, even those that describe our accountability to God and describe work as a gift from God, are consistent with the inferences we would draw from common human experience. The tone of Ecclesiastes, then, is very different from the Prophets or the Law. And, we have something far greater in the New Testament.

We also need to understand that since Ecclesiastes is a record of observation there’s a built-in limitation to the Preacher’s observations. He describes the world as it is rather than as it ought to be. In other words, the Preacher describes a fallen world, a world under a curse, a world subject to futility; not the world as it was meant to be, or as it will one day be. (see Rom 8:20-22, and compare Ecc 3:20 with Gen 3:19)

20 For the creation was subjected to futility, not willingly, but because of him who subjected it, in hope 21 that the creation itself will be set free from its bondage to decay and obtain the freedom of the glory of the children of God. 22 For we know that the whole creation has been groaning together in the pains of childbirth until now. (Rom 8:20-22 NASB)

All go to one place. All are from the dust, and to dust all return. (Ecc 3:20 NASB)

By the sweat of your face you shall eat bread, till you return to the ground, for out of it you were taken; for you are dust, and to dust you shall return. (Gen 3:19 NASB)

The book of Ecclesiastes in some ways mimics the world and its activity. It is full of beauty while at times being frustratingly obscure: celebration is juxtaposed with mourning, joy-filled poetry with hopeless prose. Mere observation reveals aspiration and aberration: eternity in our hearts compelling to create combined with despair about the significance of our creations.

Ecclesiastes rings true. It accurately portrays our experience. But, it raises many questions without fully answering them. The answers await the New Testament.


[i] This needs to be qualified. The Preacher writes in light of prior revelation, especially Genesis 2-3. All we need to do to verify this is to compare Ecc 3:20 and Gen 3:19. So, it is wrong to say that there is nothing in Ecclesiastes that goes beyond God’s revelation of himself in nature. I still think, however, that this statement is generally true and consistent with the intent of the book.

Ecclesiastes and the Workplace

Four reasons to use Ecclesiastes in a workplace Bible Study:

1) Ecclesiastes is the most extensive meditation on the meaning of labor in the Bible. Ecclesiastes begins with the question, “What does man gain by all the toil at which he toils under the sun?” and much of the book is dedicated to answering that question. There are many other portions of scripture that address work, but for the most part those portions provide us with instruction as to how best to work. For example, the book of Proverbs gives direction as to how to apply wisdom in work. It describes the difference between the wise worker and the fool, the worker who pleases God versus the worker who is a disgrace. The book of Proverbs asks “how?” Ecclesiastes asks “why?” The book of Ecclesiastes asks the more basic question: “What is the value of work? What is the purpose of work? What’s the point?” It asks the question other books take for granted.

2) Ecclesiastes gives us a good starting point for meaning-of-life discussions with our coworkers. It contains one very wise man’s ruminations about the value of work, ruminations that ring true for us all. Anyone who has thought deeply about the meaning of our labor, and asked “why?” ought to resonate with the Preacher’s observations and his conclusions. Although Ecclesiastes takes the existence of God and his activity and interest in the world into account, and interprets the meaning of our labor in light of that, this is a perspective most of us, Christian and non-Christian alike, share. The philosophy of Ecclesiastes falls short of a full-blown Christian view of work.[i] It is common ground.

3) Ecclesiastes itself claims that its own observations and conclusions are true. Even though we may find Ecclesiastes perplexing at many points and may feel dissatisfied with its seemingly incomplete conclusions, we have to acknowledge the assessment of its own teaching at the end of the book, “The Preacher sought to find words of delight, and uprightly he wrote words of truth.” (Ecc. 12:10) This is a two-fold commendation of the Preacher’s writing. He wrote “uprightly” and the words he wrote are “words of truth.”

4) The New Testament endorses the conclusions of Ecclesiastes. Paul tells us that the answers in Ecclesiastes are as good as it gets apart from the reordering of priorities brought in by the resurrection of Christ with its promise of our own future resurrection. Ecclesiastes describes a rational life. It describes the best life has to offer. This is the way our coworkers ought to live. If they have constructed their lives around their work and the well-being of their immediate families, that’s a good thing. Cocooning is rational.

Look at what Paul says in 1st Corinthians.

19 If in this life only we have hoped in Christ, we are of all people most to be pitied … 32b If the dead are not raised, "Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die." 33 Do not be deceived: "Bad company ruins good morals." (1 Cor 15:19, 32b-33)

And, compare this with Ecclesiastes:

There is nothing better for a person than that he should eat and drink and find enjoyment in his toil. This also, I saw, is from the hand of God. (Ecc 2:24, see also 3:13; 5:18; and 8:15)

Paul endorses the ruminations of Ecclesiastes. He affirms that if there is no resurrection then there is nothing better for us than to eat, drink, and pursue pleasure in our labor. That’s all there is to life. Our coworkers who live to work have it right, so long as they maintain a proper work/life balance and are conscious of an ultimate accountability to God.

The New Testament endorses the truth of Ecclesiastes – but then it claims that Easter changes everything.



[i] Both my wife and my son, Eric, have read through this and asked how this could be consistent with our belief in the absolute authority and inerrancy of the Bible. It seems weird to claim that Ecclesiastes does not present a fully Christian view of work while asserting that it is authoritative for our Christian faith and practice. I have a couple responses to this:

First, Hebrews 1:1,2 teaches clearly that all revelation prior to Christ is partial. The word translated as “in many ways” in “God spoke to our fathers through the prophets at many times and in many ways” could just as well be translated as “in many parts.” God’s revelation prior to his full, consolidating revelation in the Son, is progressive. It unfolds over time. Each revelation in the Old Testament is partial; it is a piece of the whole. Asserting the fragmentary nature of Old Testament revelation does not say that it is wrong. It remains true, but we ought to interpret it in light of the fuller revelation we have in Christ.

Second, when we claim that the Bible is inerrant, we are asserting that it is never wrong in what it affirms. It is inerrant on its own terms. Proverbs, for example, sometimes includes descriptions of what is generally true in the wise man’s observation. The diligent generally prosper while the idle suffers want. It would be wrong to think that inerrancy must imply that the diligent always prosper. That simply goes beyond the intent of the Proverb. Likewise, the Preacher is reporting his observation, which is absolutely true and without error. There is no mistake in anything he says.

Tuesday, August 17, 2004

Inductivism and Bible Study

I recently read one biblical scholar criticize another for “simple inductivism.” The scholar being criticized was Wayne Grudem; I do not remember either the critic nor the context of the criticism. It may have been in one of those “Four Views of …” or “Five Views of … “ books, probably the one dealing with miraculous gifts.


If I am right in remembering that Grudem was the target of the criticism, then I have some inkling into its meaning. Grudem is very fond of “concordance work.” He gathers all of the relevant texts having to do with a subject, then summarizes their teaching in several points or principles. I find Grudem’s approach very helpful, and am a fan of his books. In fact, I bought every member of my family their own copies of Bible Doctrines.


The inductivism comes in, I suppose, in that Grudem is making a number of observations of data – the data of Scripture – and then drawing inferences from them. The critic does not explain what is wrong with “simple inductivism” but his tone suggested that the charge alone is enough to invalidate the conclusions drawn from such an approach. This raises a question for me, “What’s wrong with simple inductivism?” Now, I don’t have access to the scholar, probably Richard Gaffin, so I can’t get a clear explanation of what he means by simple inductivism, nor as a layman am I privy to the discussions these scholars have about interpretation, but I can draw on my past studies of philosophy to interact with such statements on my own terms.


The opposite of inductivism is some form of deductivism. Generally, inductivism is associated with empiricism and deductivism is associated with rationalism; but this is not necessarily a valid association. Hypthetico-deductivism, for example, is a form of empiricist argument. The difference between these two, instead, stands in the way they define the relationship between “general, law-like statements” and specific statements. Simple inductivism assumes that general, law-like statements, or principles, are derived from observational statements. The classic example is the inference that “all crows are black.” This general statement is derived from observations of individual crows. Principles are derived from data. With deduction, the general, law-like statement is derived through some other means -- for example, by hypothesis – and specific statements are then deduced from the principle: “all men are mortal, Socrates is a man, therefore, Socrates is mortal.” “Socrates is a man” is an observational statement. “Socrates is mortal” is a specific inference which follows logically from a general, law-like statement, the premise, and this observation. With hypothetico-deductivism, these inferred statements can be tested empirically and then either corroborate or falsify the hypothesis.


The problem with “simple inductivism” is that it simply does not work. We may record several observations of crows -- “this crow is black,” “this crow is black,” “this crow is black,” and so on – but no matter how many observations we may record, we cannot guarantee that the next crow we see won’t be white. We may argue that, if every crow ever observed is black, then the statement “all crows are black” has a high probability of being true. Inductivism leads to probabilistc inferences, not the “truth-preserving” inferences of formal logic. I don’t understand, however, how we could calculate the probability of the statement being true unless we knew what portion of the entire population of crows our observations represents. But the very problem we have supposed is that we cannot know exhaustively the entire population of crows. We cannot, therefore, calculate the probability of our inference being correct. Probability is a harsh mistress. Even if we always observe heads in a string of ten coin tosses, the probability that the next toss will be heads is still only fifty percent. Drawing general principles from these simple observations, then, is not only invalid: we don’t even know how invalid it is.


Hypothetico-deductivism is supposed to address this problem. The principle, the posed hypothesis, is a tentative explanation of observations. Some other highly improbable, but testable conclusion is then derived from the hypothesis and other statements known to be true. If the conclusion passes empirical scrutiny it then adds probable weight to the hypothesis. We can even use Bayes’ theorem to recalculate the probability of the hypothesis. However, the basic problem with this is that there are, theoretically, an infinite number of possible hypotheses to explain different observations. We could come up with all sorts of hypotheses if we were just imaginative enough. At best, all we can really do is falsify a hypothesis, but there still is an infinite number left. There is no end to the process of corroboration and falsification. The likely truthfulness of the hypothesis is actually established on different grounds: its simplicity and elegance, its explanatory power – meaning its sweep – and so on.


So, philosophy still has an unresolved problem in this area: the relationship between principles, observational statements, and specific, declarative statements. However, these are the relevant issues in biblical interpretation. The problems of the philosophy of science and Systematic Theology are analogous: the principles are the summary statements of Systematic Theology, the observational statements are the data of Scripture, and the specific, declarative statements derived from the two are the implications for us.


There is no doubt we must adopt an empiricism as we approach the Scriptures. That’s inherent in they’re being authoritative. There are no a priori principles. Everything we think and do should be derived from Scripture, at least ideally. Everything is a revelation. Even the validity of logic itself hinges on our having a rational God. And, we only know that God is rational because the Bible tells us He is. (I will leave the question alone as to how we would be able to reason about logic at all without logic.)


I still do not understand why “simple inductivism” is necessarily wrong as applied to biblical interpretation. The basic flaw with observations of crows does not hold when it comes to biblical interpretation. The Bible is self-contained. It is possible to observe all the verses in the Bible about a topic. It is possible for a single individual to read through the entire Bible, even several times in his life time. It is even more possible for a community of scholars to collectively gather all texts on a topic. And, we have incredible Bible-study software to help us. The canon of Scripture is closed; crows are born and die. The population of crows is ever changing. Scripture is unchanging, despite the constant revision of Greek New Testaments. It seems to me that an approach that consists of gathering observations – finding all relevant passages dealing with a topic – and trying to summarize them in principles is eminently correct.


I am not saying there are no problems with this approach to Systematic Theology, or topical Bible study. There are several problems. One is the problem of attention. What attracts our attention in the first place? How do we decide which are the important topics to study? And how do we determine which are the relevant verses? Don’t we already have to know what a verse means to decide whether it is relevant or not, but at the same don’t we get its meaning by comparing it to other verses on the subject? Another problem is our own prejudice or preconceptions. I’m now old enough and have enough experience to know that certain communities of believers have their own cherished interpretations of verses, which mold their thinking and are unquestioned. One of the things that always amazes me is that I quote John 3:16 in the King James. I have never read a King James Bible. I have used the New American Standard since 1973, thirty-one years. I have read John 3:16 hundreds of times; it is not that I’ve never read it. My pastors have never preached from the King James Version. Yet, that is the version that is most often quoted in the evangelical community, and it is the version I can quote from memory. Now, if even the wording I use to recite a text is determined by my involvement with the evangelical community, it’s almost certain that my selection and interpretation of texts is similarly determined.


However, these problems would be common, I believe, to any alternative to “simple inductivism” as well, and would be worse. It seems to me that adopting a hypothetico-deductive or a rationalist scheme as a more realistic, and thus desirable, approach leaves the way open to flights of human imagination and a bad kind of dogmatism. It would have to accord authority to dogma or tradition that should be reserved only for Scripture. The argument in favor of such an approach is that it explicitly recognizes the problems of attention, prejudice and preconception in interpretation. The dogmatic system functions as a working hypothesis which is then constantly tested by individual observations of biblical texts. This makes sense – and is probably close to what I actually do with my use of commentaries and Confessions – but it still seems to me that we should strive for a different ideal. We should pursue the ideal of gathering all verses related to a topic and trying to derive summary principles from them. Apart from that we give up too much. We make falsification of hypotheses less likely. The discovery of biblical topics, themes, and assertions that challenge our existing views would be less frequent. We would rule out too much a priori, as does the critic with miraculous gifts.


So, the conclusion I draw from this rant, is that I will make “inductivism” a goal. I will continue to try to gather an exhaustive collection of biblical observations on a topic (with the help of my software) and derive principles from them. I will apply my own dogmatic commitments (Reformed, Baptist, Charismatic) to organize my materials, conceding the need for a "hypothesis" in selecting texts, but I will also continually test my resulting outlines against my observations. For example, I am tentatively using a modified ordo salutis to organize my presentation of the ministry of the Spirit in the lives of believers, but I will review my list of 539 biblical texts on the Spirit’s ministry to ensure that this outline makes sense.

Sunday, August 08, 2004

A Brief Meditation on Eph 1:11

Eph 1:11

also we we have obtained an inheritance, having been predestined according to His purpose who works all things after the counsel of His will

This is a brief meditation on this one verse, especially on the final phrase, "who works all things after the counsel of His will."

The verse occurs within an extended outburst of praise, "Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ." Paul's thoughts are filled with the glory and overflowing majesty of God. Yet, he never explicitly defines God for us -- not in the way systematic theologies or confessions of faith do. He presupposes a common understanding of God, probably because instruction about the nature of God was a part of his evangelistic teaching. Two brief sermons we have from him in Acts to the Gentiles draw out the implications of the Jewish/Christian view of God as creator. (see his sermon at Lystra in Acts 14 and to the Athenians in Acts 17.) We can only assume that these offer a glimpse into his constant practice. On occasion he appeals to the character of God in an ad hoc manner in the course of making an argument, reporting a prayer, or exhorting his readers. Often these are in the form of short relative clauses, such as this one, which we may tend to overlook but which are rich in information about the nature of God. We ought to linger over them.

What does this phrase, "who works all things after the counsel of His will," tell us about God?

1. God is personal. He has motives, thoughts, purpose. He has a will and mind. He is not an impersonal force, principle or law. He is not a universal energy.

2. God is rational. He acts rationally. He has reasons for what he does. He chooses a purpose and acts to fulfill that purpose. He is not arbitrary or irrational.

3. God is consistent. He is not inconsistent and changeable. He does not waver from his own purpose. He is faithful.

4. God is active. Not passive. He works. He acts within time though he transcends time. One day is as a thousand years and a thousand years as one day. His eternity doesn’t mean just a long time. He exists outside of time; both time and space are His creation. However, He is somehow still able to truly act within space and time.

5. God is independent. He is not constrained by anything outside Himself. His will is the ultimate explanation for all things. He sets His love on Israel because He loves them. This does not mean He is arbitrary; it means the explanation for His actions are within Himself. He is absolutely free.

6. God is sovereign. He is sovereignly powerful over all things. Possible exceptions -- random events or chance; acts of the devil and demons; the free, responsible acts of human beings; my own sins -- are found not to be exceptions in the Scriptures.


How should we respond?

We lose if we hold to a truncated view of God. Currently, some authors are arguing that these points are mutually exclusive: God can’t truly be personal in the sense that He can enter into a genuine relationship with His creatures unless He also limits His sovereignty and foreknowledge. Paul's letter to the Ephesians by itself refutes this claim. Chapter 1 presents a beautiful picture of three motives of God coinciding: His zeal for His own glory, His intense love for the Son, and His passionate determination to bless His people. That is the majesty of the gospel and the source of all comfort -- God is both absolutely sovereign and a resolutely gracious Personal Father.

Assurance. Even though “we have obtained an inheritance” is in past tense, our full enjoyment of this inheritance and consummation of all the promises of God toward us are still in the future. But Paul grounds our assurance of the future on the very character of God. He gives us two reasons for being sure: God’s working all things for us and the Spirit’s work within us (see following verse). The ground of both of these is the very nature and character of God.

Comfort. The corollary to God being rational, active and sovereign over all things, is that every thing that happens has a reason. I do not understand those who find it more comforting to believe either that some things happen purely by chance or that God’s knowledge and power are somehow limited. The issue seems to be a question about the character of God. We need to trust in God’s kindness, goodness, wisdom, power, grace, first. Then, we can trust that a good and gracious, all-wise, all-powerful God has his own good reasons for letting some things occur. Somehow the explanation for these things can be reconciled with His goodness though we ourselves cannot reconcile them. This is far more comforting to me than to think that God is either too weak or too stupid to prevent calamity.

Purposeful activity. We glorify God and fulfill His purpose for us by imitating Him. We may be tempted to think God’s sovereignty over all things would lead us to be passive, or diminish our significance as “real causes.” But this is philosophy, not Christian revelation. We were created in His image -- to image Him forth. We, therefore, fulfill His purpose for us, we worship Him, when we set goals and fulfill them, when we work. Work is worship!


Friday, August 06, 2004

Reading and Citizenship

Evangelical Christians of all people ought to be most committed to searching out and studying primary source material.

We believe that the authority of scripture necessarily implies an approach to biblical interpretation that seeks to discover the meaning of a text in the Author’s intent and not in the reader’s response. It is not satisfied with secondary sources, but instead seeks to enter into the mind of its Author. The meaning of the text transcends its readers’ immediate thoughts and experience. It is something to which we aspire to attain, to comprehend, rather than something confined to our ready-made subjectivism. Study of the text requires painstaking, self-suspicious effort.

Beyond the Bible’s authority as the word of God, our call to pursue sanctification also demands a rigorously careful interpretation of scripture, and implies a specific philosophy of interpretation. “Unity in the faith,” that is, a common understanding of doctrine, is a measure of our Christ-likeness and is an important aspect of our growth in conformity into his image. Seeking doctrinal unity remains a constant duty for us as long as we live. There is just one right faith, not a multitude of equally valid “faiths,” and just one valid interpretation of scripture. If there were a number of “faiths” then we would be urged to unity in spite of faith and not in it. (see Eph 4:13 in context.)

But our sanctification is never complete in this life; neither is our understanding of scripture. Perfect agreement in the Church is unattainable. Nevertheless, our responsibility stands: we are called to devote ourselves to continual, earnest dialogue with others about the meaning of the text. This dialogue ought to characterize our interactions with each other in small groups and in worship services. It is an integral part of the body life of the Church. We are called, literally, to “truth it” with one another in love. (Eph 4:15, Greek)

Even though we can affirm some of the very same premises postmodernists use to argue for the “death of the author” and to posit a reader-response theory of the meaning of a text – the impossibility of perfect objectivity, our propensity toward self-justifying distortion, the problem of discerning another’s intent – we cannot follow them in their desperate abandonment to radical subjectivism. We believe the concept of divine revelation implies the efficacy of the Author’s communication. And we assert that the Holy Spirit guides us into the truth by enabling us to understand what is “out there” in the text and by progressively liberating us from the cognitive effects of our innate sinfulness.

Unfortunately, we are often, in our popular preaching and in our Bible study, in such a rush to apply scripture that we act as though the meaning of the text is “what it means to us, today,” that is, its meaning consists in its existential, subjective, contemporary significance rather than its objective, historical meaning. We skip the toil of studying grammar, idiom, rhetoric, historical and logical context, flow of argument, and so on, in order to make the text personally relevant, ignoring that this in itself often puts the lie to our confession of the unique authority of scripture. We define relevance for ourselves rather than letting scripture define it for us.

Christians are, in a sense, given a philosophy of the interpretation of texts: the importance of the author’s intent, the responsibility to interact with primary sources, the community’s role in continual refinement of our understanding, the assertion of the possibility of valid interpretation even though perfect interpretation is unattainable.

We ought to apply this philosophy of interpretation in our exercise of responsible citizenship, as well. All of us ought to read “The 9/11 Commission Report” and the Supreme Court’s opinions in “Lawrence v. Texas” before voting this year.

Saturday, July 31, 2004

Humpty Dumpty Theology

In an opinion piece in the Hartford Courant, Davida Foy Crabtree described the United Church of Christ as a community of people and churches who “take the Bible too seriously to take it literally” (http://www.ctucc.org/news/dfconucc0604.html) When I read that, I felt like Alice in Lewis Carroll’s, Through the Looking Glass.


“There’s glory for you!”

“I don’t know what you mean by ‘glory,’” Alice said.

Humpty Dumpty smiled contemptuously. “Of course you don’t—till I tell you. I meant ‘there’s a nice knock-down argument for you!”

But ‘glory’ doesn’t mean ‘a nice knock-down argument’,” Alice objected.

“When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it too mean—neither more nor less.”

“The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can make words mean so many different things.”

“Impenetrability! That’s what I say!”

“Would you tell me please,” said Alice, “what that means?”

“Now you talk like a reasonable child,” said Humpty Dumpty, “ … I meant by ‘impenetrability’ that we’ve had enough of that subject, and that it would be just as well if you’d mention what you suppose to do next, as I suppose you don’t mean to stop here all the rest of your life.”

“That’s a great deal to make one word mean,” Alice said in a thoughtful tone.

“When I make a word do a lot of work like that,” said Humpty Dumpty, “I always pay it extra.”

Apparently, for Ms. Crabtree serious biblical interpretation implies paying words extra. Those of us who consider ourselves “evangelicals” or “conservatives,” whom she might call “literalists,” are unreasonable Alices. We want words to mean something. We expect texts to be important. And, we want to pay attention to what a text actually says.

We, too, as she admirably expresses the aspirations of the people of the UCC, do not want to “shy away from applying the faith to every aspect of our lives.” The difference is that we think “the faith” has content and meaning that is defined for us and which we look to discover, rather than to invent.

We hope and pray that our social, cultural, and political institutions do not share her Humpty Dumpty approach to interpretation of texts. We hope, for example, that the Supreme Court doesn’t take the Constitution too seriously to pay attention to what it actually says.

No thanks, Mr. Kerry !

This past Thursday at the Democratic National Convention, John Kerry issued an invitation to people of faith, "And let me say it plainly: in that cause, and in this campaign, we welcome people of faith." Speaking as a person of faith I can only say, "No thanks, Mr. Kerry! I decline your invitation." Let me explain why.

It is not at all clear what the cause is to which you're inviting people of faith. Is it in taking the high road in the election, "My friends, the high road may be harder, but it leads to a better place?" I'm not sure where your "high road" is located; it must be just a couple inches above sea level. In spite of all your claims to the contrary, your speech was full of Michael Moore-like insinuation, insult and innuendo. Your statement, "I want an America that relies on its own ingenuity and innovation -- not the Saudi royal family" could have been lifted directly from Farenheit 911. You accused President Bush of lying to the American people, deliberately misleading us into war, and distorting facts offered by the intelligence community for political purposes. You accused the Vice President of conducting secret meetings with polluters. And, you reserved your greatest slander for the Attorney General of the US, insinuating that he has corrupted the Constitution of the United States he has sworn to uphold. Many of us suspect that you and others find Mr. Ashcroft particularly distatsteful precisely because he is a man of faith.

No, Mr. Kerry, the high road is a high road of truth. It does not embrace and spread propaganda while pretending not to. Your campaign has been filled with personal attacks on your opponents at the same time you claim a "positive message."

Is the cause you're inviting us to that of making "this election a contest of big ideas" in the place of "small-minded attacks" "misus[ing[ for political purposes the most precious document in American history, the Constitution of the United States?" I question whether there is anything more important than a wide-spread citizens' discussion about the rule of law versus the rule of judges. The Supreme Court has been tinkering with the Constitution for years, finding new rights where none previously existed, sometimes overturning previous decisions because of a gathering consensus in the lawyers' guild, sometimes asserting that the credibility of the court is at stake in continuing to affirm previous decisions in spite of controversy. People of faith have been shocked out of their complacency by recent opinions issued by the Supreme Court in which an "emerging awareness" somehow discernable to judges apart from any explicit democratic expression now trumps "practices ... firmly rooted in Judeao-Christian moral and ethical standards," where rights not enumerated in the Constitution can now be found by a cloistered judge's observation of the past 50 years of degenerate human history. (see Lawrence v. Texas)

No, Mr. Kerry, the Constitution, and the rule of law, are big ideas. Not letting people of faith discuss the intellectual and ethical foundations of our society are small minded to the extreme.

The conditions of your invitation are too onerous for me. People of faith are welcome to join your campaign only on the condition that they not "wear their faith on their sleeve." That is, we are welcome only if our faith doesn't require anything of us, if it doesn't inform our moral judgments, if it doesn't require any action, if the values we derive from our faith comfort but don't compel. We are only welcome if we embrace inconsistency. We are welcome only if we are comfortable believing one thing and doing another.

No, Mr. Kerry, I have seen your inconsistency. I decline your invitation.